It is a cheap idea to support how united the countries from
the Middle Eastern area are. In fact, with the exception of their hate against
Israel – as a tool to excuse their disregard for basic rights for their
citizens - and the support for the extremist Palestinian factions, there is no
interest in going and acting together.
As Syria is in the news – but not in the minds of the
decision makers – daily, the old and deepening conflict between Syria and Turkey I decided that I should start looking more carefully to the history of the bilateral relations between Damascus and Ankara.
Overall diplomatic framework
Syria has an embassy in Ankara and two consulate general in
Istanbul and Gaziantep. Turkey has besides the embassy in Damascus one
consulate general in Aleppo.
Both Turkey and Syria are members of the Organisation of Islamic
Cooperation (OIC) and of the Union for the Mediterranean.
The relation between Damascus and Ankara were molded at a
great extent by the so-called ‘independence’ attitude of the new authorities in
Ankara – to be read more tempted to follow the usual religious oriented
patterns. Within the various Islamic fora, Turkey was often accused of being a
Trojan horse, due also to the previous good relationships with the state of Israel,
and its prestigious position in NATO. Many Muslim countries clapped their hands
when the Turkish Parliament refused in 2003 to cooperate militarily with the US
for the invasion in Iraq.
In 2004, Assad was the first ever president that ever went to
Ankara in a state visit. In 2008, Turkey started to play the role of mediator
between Damascus and Jerusalem on the issue of the Golan Heights, but it gave
up its neutral role after qualifying the 2008-2009 operation in Gaza as ‘crimes
against humanity’ committed by the Israeli Defense Army. On 26 April 2009,
Syria and Turkey organized three-day joint military exercise developed in the
border areas.
The casus belli
There are a couple of points that marked regularly the
relations between the two countries:
- - The 1939 conflict regarding the annexation of the
Hatay Province to Turkey. Hatay Province won in 1938 independence from the
French Mandate of Syria and as the Republic of Hatay decided to join Turkey
through a referendum that was never recognized by Damascus. Even though the province
appears on many maps in Syria as still being part of this country, following
the historical visit to Ankara, Assad declared that Damascus has no more
interests in winning back the province. According to various media reports, it
is said that many Syrian nationals bought in the last years properties in this
Turkish region.
- - The water dispute within the Southeastern Anatolia
Project refers to the decision ot Turkey to build several dams on the Euphrates
and Tigris rivers
- - Syria’s open support for the Kurds. Repeatedly, it was
alleged that Kurdish separatists were trained in Syria by one of the most
sought Nazi war criminals, Alois Brunner who apparently was received open arms
here Eastern Syria – or what the Kurds
call Western Kurdistan – is home for more than 2 million Kurds who should be
considered in any discussions regarding the future of the region. However, in October
1998, the Syrian authorities decided to expel the Kurd leader Abdullah Öcalan
to Turkey where he was put in prison, following unprecedented tensions when the
Turkish tanks were deployed at the border. In the coming months, the issue of
the Kurdish minority will continue to be at stake, as Turkey clearly outlined
that it will not accept the creation of a Kurdish entity within Syria.
-
The recent evolutions
The immediate effect on the current
uprising on the bilateral relations was the high number of refugees – around 300,000
that flew to Turkey at the beginning of the conflict. The same Erdogan that
hold hands with Assad declared to the Anatolian Agency that “Syria is not
acting in a human manner. This is savagery”. Part of the change of perspective
was the serious incident that took place a couple of months ago after on 22
June 2012, Syria shot down a Turkish F-4 Phantom military jet near the
Turkish-Syrian border, due to what the Syrian military
alleged it was a violation of the Syrian airspace by Turkey. In the last years,
Assad decided to grant Syrian citizenship to some Kurds another example that,
in fact, in many Middle Eastern countries, governments are not acting for the
sake of an idea, but rather against a particular other.
Despite the recent political turmoil in Ankara, Turkey continues
to be an important NATO member and a candidate country to the EU. Even though
the Cold War is over, some of the disagreements could be included on the old bill
that Russia will never ask to be paid from the US in the Middle East. After officially
losing the control in Central and Eastern Europe, Moscow could be as desperate
as to negotiate some influence in the Middle East and thus cannot accept by
itself to loose Syria (too).